A new report suggests so.
The Female FTSE Board Report, published by Cranfield University’s School of Management claims that women are being given board appointments at FTSE 100 companies for ‘symbolic value’ as they serve a shorter tenure than their male counterparts.
On average, non-executive female directors serve nearly four years (3.8) years compared to five years served by men.
Gender diversity on boards is improving – but slowly
In his introduction to the report, Stephen Haddrill, Chief Executive of the Financial Reporting Council, says that while it’s ‘encouraging’ that the proportion of women on boards is still increasing, it’s ‘concerning’ that women are in executive roles in only a quarter of FTSE100 companies.
Although it’s recognised that a female perspective is a valuable addition to a board of directors, and that having diverse viewpoints is a plus, directors mostly persist in appointing new members in their own image – largely male, middle-aged and from similar socioeconomic backgrounds.
We’ve looked into this issue before, exploring the 10 reasons firms give for having no women on the board.
And if women are being appointed to ‘tick a box’, then is that really progress?
Sue Vinnicombe, professor of women and leadership at Cranfield University, and lead author of the report, said:
‘There has clearly been great progress on the numbers front but scratch beneath the surface and we suggest that some companies have simply been ticking a box.’
Gender isn’t the only challenge when it comes to diverse boards
Although the percentage of women on FTSE 100 boards is on track to reach 33 per cent by 2020, only 11% of women on boards currently are from Black, Asian and minority ethnic (BAME) backgrounds.
‘While I welcome positive progress at some of the UK’s largest companies in appointing more women to board level roles, it is clear more needs to be done to promote diversity across all levels of FTSE companies.’
Why are women good for boards?
Having females on boards – and not just as a token gesture – has many recognised benefits:
- Firms with a diverse leadership tend to be more profitable, according to research by Grant Thornton.
- Women can help make better decisions. It’s been suggested that the female brain may be the secret weapon of the best boards, with typically female characteristics such as empathy, intuition and creativity valuable to making considered decisions.
- Demonstrating gravitas and authority without being over-bearing is often seen as another female strength. Research has found that this was one of the attributes shared by successful directors.
- Many of the qualities that are seen as important in board members – an eye for detail; the ability to constructively but sympathetically debate issues – are also often seen as things that women have an affinity for.
- The best decisions come from diverse boards that display a range of views. Research into the ideal mix of perspectives in the boardroom shows that having a good of blend of opinions, skills and experience will help you to avoid groupthink, herding and the other behavioural tendencies that hinder good decisions.
Of course, having women on the board is not the only secret to success when it comes to good decision making and a strong, effective board.
You need to ensure your directors have all the information they need to make informed decisions. Following best practice around meetings is also important – ensuring members are well-prepared for meetings, giving your meetings a clear purpose, making sure they are chaired effectively and providing user-friendly board packs.
Many boards are finding that using board portals to produce their papers delivers big improvements in terms of efficiency, user-friendliness and information sharing.
Nothing in this document should be treated as an authoritative statement of the law. Action should not be taken as a result of this document alone. We make no warranty and accept no responsibility for consequences arising from relying on this document.